Medigap premiums can rise with age, with inflation or with a rate filing, and many policyholders then ask whether they can move to another Medicare Supplement plan. You can apply in any month, but a new insurer is only required to accept you in set situations. Outside them, the insurer may ask about your health, charge more or decline, as medicare.gov explains on its page about changing policies, checked on November 20, 2026.
Below: the table of situations where the insurer cannot turn you down, each with its deadline, the 30-day free look period, and the state rules that add rights. Related pages cover the Medicare birthday rule and Medigap guaranteed issue rights. This page is information only.
Coverage Breakdown
Direct answer: can you change Medigap plans at any time?
No. You can apply to switch Medigap plans in any month, but outside your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period or a guaranteed issue right, the insurer may ask health questions and turn you down. Medicare.gov says most people have no federal right to switch. Some states, including Connecticut and New York, and 16 birthday-rule states, add rights.
What federal law says about switching Medicare Supplement plans
Medigap, also called Medicare Supplement Insurance, is private coverage that pays some of what Original Medicare Part A and Part B leave behind. Medicare.gov's page on changing policies says that in most cases you won't have a right under federal law to switch Medigap policies. You can switch if you are in your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, or if you qualify for a situation where an insurer can't deny you a policy, called a guaranteed issue right. Nothing stops you from applying in any other month, and Medigap has no yearly sign-up season. The difference is that outside those two cases the insurer decides whether to sell you the policy, what to charge, and which health history to count.
Medicare.gov also says that when you can buy a policy outside those windows, it may cost more because of past or present health problems. A person who is healthy now may pass health questions; a person with a new diagnosis may not. That risk is the reason to confirm approval before you give up a plan you already have.
Situations where the insurer cannot turn you down, with deadlines
The table above lists the federal situations in which a Medigap insurer must sell you a policy. In each one, the insurer must cover your pre-existing conditions and can't charge more because of your health. Most deadlines are measured from the day your old coverage ends, and Medicare.gov says to keep the letters, notices, emails or claim denials that show the date, because the new insurer may ask for them.
Worked example: a Medicare Advantage plan ends December 31, 2026 because it leaves your area, and you return to Original Medicare. Your guaranteed issue window runs from November 1, 2026 to March 4, 2027. An application dated March 5, 2027 falls outside it, and the insurer may ask health questions. Joining another Medicare Advantage plan instead does not give you this Medigap right.
Your premium went up: what the rules mean for a switch
A premium increase alone is not one of the federal guaranteed issue situations. If you have had your Medigap policy for years and are outside every window in the table, a new insurer may ask health questions before it sells you any plan. Medigap policies with the same letter, such as Plan G, offer the same basic benefits no matter which insurer sells them in most states, so a same-letter switch changes the price and the insurer, not the benefits. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin standardize plans differently.
Before you apply, check whether your state gives you a right the federal list does not. Sixteen states have a birthday rule that lets Medigap holders switch once a year without health questions, and Connecticut and New York allow guaranteed issue all year (KFF, October 13, 2026). See the Medicare birthday rule page for each state's window. Plan comparison and pricing are handled by a licensed agent or the plan finder at medicare.gov.
- Federal rights: the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period and the guaranteed issue situations in the table
- State rights: birthday rule in 16 states, all-year guaranteed issue in Connecticut and New York
- Everything else: the insurer may ask health questions, charge more or decline
The 30-day free look period when you switch
Medicare.gov says a new Medigap policy comes with a 30-day free look period to decide whether to keep it. Do not cancel your first policy until you have decided to keep the second one. You will pay both premiums for the month you have both. Medicare.gov also warns that if you drop a policy, you might not be able to get it back later, so confirm that the new insurer has approved you and set your start date before you contact your current insurer to cancel.
A second caution from medicare.gov: if you switch within 6 months of when your current policy started, the new insurer may make you wait before it covers a pre-existing condition. Ask the new insurer in writing how it counts the time you have had your current policy.
Alternatives if you are outside every window
If none of the situations in the table fits, you still have next steps. Each one below names where to find it.
- Check your state's rule: call your state insurance department or State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP, shiphelp.org) about a birthday rule or all-year right.
- Apply and ask: you may apply to any insurer in any month, and an insurer may approve you after health questions. Do not cancel your current plan until you have the approval in writing.
- Keep your current policy and compare it: a licensed agent or the plan finder at medicare.gov/plan-compare handles price comparison.
- Review Medigap versus Medicare Advantage: leaving Medigap for Medicare Advantage is a different choice with its own trial right (see the guaranteed issue page).
- Ask the SHIP about help paying premiums: a Medicare Savings Program or Medicaid may lower costs, depending on income.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change Medicare Supplement plans anytime I want?
You can apply in any month, but you do not have a federal right to switch. Medicare.gov says that in most cases you can switch only during your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period or in a guaranteed issue situation. Otherwise the insurer may ask health questions, charge more or decline your application.
When can I change Medicare Supplement plans without health questions?
You can switch without health questions during your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period or when you have a guaranteed issue right, such as your Medicare Advantage plan ending or an employer or retiree plan that pays after Medicare ending. Most deadlines are 63 days after the old coverage ends. Some states add rights.
My Medigap premium went up this year. Can I switch to a cheaper plan?
You can apply to any insurer, but a premium increase is not a federal guaranteed issue situation. Outside your open enrollment period, the new insurer may ask health questions and decline you. Check your state for a birthday rule or all-year right first, and keep your current plan until you are approved in writing.
I live in New York. Can I change Medigap plans any time of year?
Connecticut and New York require continuous guaranteed issue, according to KFF's October 13, 2026 review, so insurers there must sell you a Medigap policy at any time of year. Confirm the exact rule and which plans qualify with your state insurance department or SHIP before you cancel anything.
I turn 70 next July in California. Can I switch Medigap plans then?
California has a birthday rule: a 60-day window each year that starts on your birthday, to switch to an equal or lesser plan without health questions. For a July 18, 2027 birthday the window would run July 18 to September 15, 2027. Check the Medicare birthday rule page and the California Department of Insurance.
Is there a trial period when I switch to a new Medigap policy?
Yes. Medicare.gov says a new Medigap policy has a 30-day free look period to decide whether to keep it. Do not cancel your first policy until you decide to keep the second. You will pay both premiums for the month you have both policies.
My Medicare Advantage plan ends December 31, 2026. How long do I have to buy Medigap without health questions?
If you return to Original Medicare, you can apply from 60 days before your plan coverage ends to 63 days after it ends. For a December 31, 2026 end date, that is November 1, 2026 to March 4, 2027. Joining another Medicare Advantage plan instead does not give you this right.
If I drop my Medigap plan, can I get it back later?
Not necessarily. Medicare.gov warns that if you drop a Medigap policy you might not be able to get it back. Outside a guaranteed issue right or open enrollment, an insurer can ask health questions first. Wait until your new policy is approved and active before you cancel the old one.