Already have a Medigap policy and wondering whether you can move to a cheaper one without health questions? The Medigap birthday rule is a state law that opens a yearly window around your birthday for exactly that. KFF counted 16 states with one on October 13, 2026. The table below covers each of them, California first, with how long the window is, when it opens and what you may switch to. Every row was checked against an official state page on November 16, 2026. The page is information only, and CoveredUSA is not selling or recommending any insurer.
Coverage Breakdown
Direct answer: 16 states have a Medigap birthday rule
Yes, 16 states have a Medigap birthday rule: a state law that lets someone who already has a Medigap policy switch plans once a year, around a birthday, without health questions (KFF, October 13, 2026). Windows run from about 2 months to 63 days or more, and most limit you to the same or lesser benefits. Original Medicare has no federal version, so elsewhere an insurer may ask health questions.
What the Medigap birthday rule is, and what Original Medicare does not offer
Federal law gives you one main guaranteed chance to buy any Medigap policy: the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period that starts when you are 65 or older and have Medicare Part B. After that, the CMS guide Choosing a Medigap Policy says that in most cases you have no right under federal law to switch Medigap policies unless you are in that window or in a specific guaranteed issue situation. Original Medicare, which is Part A and Part B, sets no yearly switching right. Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance) is private insurance regulated by the states, so the states can add rights, and 16 of them have.
A birthday rule is one of those state additions. If you already have a Medigap policy, the state opens a yearly window around your birthday. During it, an insurer cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health, and California's Department of Insurance describes the switch as one made without a medical screening or a new waiting period, so a preexisting condition does not block the move. The new policy still has to fit the state's limits on which plans you can pick, which is the third column of the table above. The rule is for people who already hold a Medigap policy. It does not give someone on Medicare Advantage a way into Medigap, and it does not change Medicare Part D drug coverage, which is bought separately.
California Medigap birthday rule in detail
California gives anyone with a Medigap policy a 60-day window each year that starts on the birthday itself. The California Department of Insurance's Senior Insurance Bill of Rights guide (July 2025) says you have a right to transfer to an equal or lesser Medicare Supplement plan during the 60-day open enrollment period commencing with your birthday, and it cites California Insurance Code section 10192.11(h). The Department's senior advisory on Medigap adds that you can buy a new policy in that window without a medical screening or a new waiting period, as long as the new policy has the same or lesser benefits than the old one.
California insurers must tell you about this right in writing at least 30 and no more than 60 days before your birthday, according to the same Department guide. A California Medigap holder whose birthday falls on July 18 gets that notice between May 19 and June 18, and the window runs July 18 through September 15. Because the rule only protects a move to equal or lesser benefits, going from a Plan G to a Plan N counts as lesser on the plan charts other states publish, while going from a Plan N up to a Plan G is not covered and the new insurer may ask health questions. The Department's pages do not say whether the new plan must come from your current insurer, so ask the Department of Insurance or the California Health Insurance Counseling and Advocacy Program (HICAP, 1-800-434-0222, a free state counseling service) before you apply.
How the windows differ in the other 15 states
Delaware, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Nevada, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Oregon, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia and Wyoming copy the idea but not the details. Windows start on your birthday in most of them, on the first day of your birthday month in Nevada, New Mexico and West Virginia, and before your birthday in Delaware (30 days), Indiana (1 month) and Oregon (30 days). Lengths run from 45 days in Illinois to 63 days in Idaho, Louisiana and Wyoming. Maryland guarantees your birthday plus the 30 days after it, and an insurer may offer more.
The bigger differences are in what you may buy. Kentucky and Indiana guarantee only the same plan from a different insurer, so a Plan G holder is guaranteed a Plan G elsewhere but not a drop to Plan N. Virginia guarantees only the same benefits. Utah, Illinois, Louisiana and West Virginia keep you with your current insurer or its affiliate, so the rule helps you pick a lesser plan, not shop other companies. Illinois covers only ages 65 to 75. West Virginia requires your policy to have been in force 24 months and allows one use per calendar year. Oklahoma requires no gap in coverage longer than 90 days. Maryland and West Virginia treat the window as an application window, so the application must go in during the window even if processing finishes later.
- Delaware: in effect January 1, 2026 (Senate Bill 71).
- Indiana: in effect January 1, 2026; the window now runs 1 month before through 1 month after your birthday.
- Virginia: in effect July 1, 2025. Utah: May 7, 2025. Wyoming: rule applies to replacements on or after June 1, 2025.
- West Virginia: law passed March 13, 2026, in effect 90 days after passage.
- New Mexico: signed March 2026, starts January 1, 2027.
Worked example: two birthdays, two states, real dates
Ana lives in California, has had a Medigap Plan G since 2024, and turns 70 on July 18, 2027. Her insurer's notice should arrive between May 19 and June 18, 2027. Her 60-day window runs July 18, 2027 through September 15, 2027. She can apply for a Plan N, a lesser plan, inside that window and the new insurer cannot ask about the diabetes she was diagnosed with in 2026. If she applies on September 20, the window has closed and the insurer may underwrite her.
Bob lives in Illinois, has a Medigap policy, and turns 70 on October 5, 2027. Illinois gives him 45 days starting on his birthday, so his window runs October 5, 2027 through November 18, 2027. He can choose any plan with equal or lesser benefits, but only from his current company or an affiliate. If Bob were 76 on that birthday, Illinois would not give him the window at all, because the Illinois Department on Aging's 2026 guide limits it to ages 65 to 75.
What the birthday rule does not do
A birthday rule is a narrow right, and four limits catch people. First, it is for Medigap holders only: Delaware's Department of Insurance says it applies only to consumers who switch from one Medigap policy to another, and Indiana's Department of Insurance SHIP program says it does not give someone on Medicare Advantage a guaranteed way into a Medigap policy. Second, it does not lock in a lower premium. Indiana's SHIP notes insurers can still set premiums by age, gender, ZIP code and tobacco use, so compare the premium for the same plan before you move. Third, richer plans are not protected, so a move up to a plan with more benefits can bring health questions. Fourth, some states cover only certain people, such as Illinois (ages 65 to 75) and West Virginia (policies in force 24 months).
Do not cancel your old policy first. The CMS guide says that if you switch, you should not cancel your first Medigap policy until you have decided to keep the second one, and you will pay both premiums for any month you hold both. You have 30 days after you get the new policy to decide whether to keep it. Delaware and Nevada also say their rule covers a policy bought in that state by someone who still lives there, not a policy bought there by someone who has since moved out of state.
If your state has no birthday rule: your other options
Outside the 16 states, federal rules apply: the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period and the guaranteed issue situations listed in the CMS guide, such as losing certain coverage, with windows that are often 63 days. Outside those, an insurer may ask health questions and decline you or charge more, though you may still apply to any insurer willing to accept you. KFF's October 13, 2026 review lists states with other rights, and the list below names the next steps with where to find each one.
- Connecticut and New York: continuous open enrollment with guaranteed issue throughout the year (KFF, October 13, 2026).
- Massachusetts: regulations require an annual guaranteed period, and Maine requires guaranteed issue for one month every year for at least Plan A (KFF).
- Missouri: current Medigap holders may switch to an equivalent policy from a different insurer in a window around their policy's anniversary date, an anniversary rule rather than a birthday rule (KFF).
- Federal guaranteed issue situations: read pages 17 to 18 of the CMS guide Choosing a Medigap Policy at medicare.gov.
- Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) and your state insurance department: both can confirm what your state allows today, at no cost to you.
How to check your state's rule on the day you apply
State birthday rules changed in 2025 and 2026, and Indiana already changed its window after its first year, so a page written months ago can be wrong. Before you apply, open your state insurance department's Medicare supplement page, note the start and end dates of your window, and write down your current plan letter and policy number. Ask the new insurer to confirm in writing that your application date falls inside the window. For the plan-comparison step, a licensed agent or the plan finder at medicare.gov handles the choice of insurer, and CoveredUSA does not compare or recommend insurers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which states have the Medigap birthday rule, and which one is the newest?
KFF counted 16 states on October 13, 2026: California, Delaware, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Nevada, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Oregon, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia and Wyoming. New Mexico is the newest to start: its law, signed in March 2026, begins January 1, 2027. Delaware and Indiana began January 1, 2026. Check your state's insurance department for the current window.
I live in California and my birthday is July 18, 2027. When can I switch my Medigap plan without health questions?
Your California window runs July 18, 2027 through September 15, 2027, 60 days counting your birthday as day 1. The California Department of Insurance says insurers must notify you 30 to 60 days before your birthday, so look for a notice between May 19 and June 18, 2027. The new plan must have equal or lesser benefits than your current one.
I have a Plan G and live in Indiana. Can I use the birthday rule to drop to a Plan N?
Probably not with a guarantee. Indiana's SHIP program, run by the Department of Insurance, says the law guarantees you only the same lettered plan from a new company. A Plan G holder is guaranteed a Plan G elsewhere, not a Plan N or a Plan F. Kentucky works the same way. Nevada, Maryland and California allow equal or lesser plans.
I am 77 and live in Illinois. Does the Illinois birthday rule still cover me?
No. The Illinois Department on Aging's 2026 Medicare guide says the yearly 45-day window is for people at least 65 but no more than 75 who already have a Medigap policy. At 77 you would rely on other Medigap rights, and an insurer may ask health questions. Confirm with the Illinois Department of Insurance.
I am on a Medicare Advantage plan at 68 and want a Medigap policy. Does the birthday rule get me one without health questions?
No. The birthday rule is for people who already have a Medigap policy. Delaware says it applies only to consumers switching from one Medigap policy to another, and Indiana's SHIP says it gives no guaranteed Medigap rights to someone on Medicare Advantage. Moving from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare is governed by federal enrollment periods.
I live in Texas, which is not on the list. Can I still switch my Medigap plan for a lower premium?
Yes, but without a guarantee. Federal law gives no yearly right, per the CMS guide Choosing a Medigap Policy, so an insurer may ask health questions, decline you, or charge more. You can still apply to any insurer willing to sell you the policy. Your state insurance department or SHIP can say whether Texas adds rights.
I bought my Medigap policy in Nevada but moved to Arizona. Does the Nevada birthday rule follow me?
No. Nevada's Division of Insurance guidance says the rule does not apply to policyholders who purchased a plan in Nevada and now live out of state. Delaware's guidance says the same. It does cover someone who bought out of state and now lives in Nevada, which the Division expects carriers to honor once they know.
My Maryland birthday is November 10, 2026 and my new insurer has not finished underwriting. Do I lose the window?
Not for that reason. The Maryland Insurance Administration says the application must be submitted during the window, but nothing legally requires that it be fully processed inside it. Your window includes November 10, 2026 and the 30 days after, through December 10, 2026. Submit before December 10, 2026 and keep proof of the submission date.